A Bengaluru civil court dismissed an outsourcing company's suit against a former employee. The ruling restates what a confidentiality clause can and cannot do, and shows how much depends on the employer's evidence.
The short version
On 6 October 2026, the XXXV Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru (JV Kulkarni) dismissed O.S. No. 3154/2023, M/s EOX Vantage Private Limited v. Shruthi B.S., with costs 1. The company had asked for a permanent injunction against its former Assistant Manager (Operations). It wanted her barred from soliciting its employees and clients and from disclosing confidential information under her non-disclosure agreement (NDA).
Two ideas run through the judgment. First, an employer cannot use a confidentiality clause to stop an ex-employee from joining a competitor, because of Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. Second, an employer who alleges data theft and poaching has to prove it with reliable evidence, and EOX did not.
The dispute: alleged data leakage, client solicitation and poaching
EOX Vantage provides back-office and knowledge process outsourcing services. Shruthi had joined a predecessor company in 2011 and later held a senior operations role with wide access to client and employee data. The company's case was that, after she resigned, she:
- worked with a rival, Conscala Private Limited, and later as a consultant for GMI Insurance, which was an EOX client;
- along with two former colleagues who are defendants in connected suits, leaked confidential information and tried to poach clients and employees;
- forwarded rate cards, contracts and other material to her personal email over three to five years, according to an internal investigation.
EOX put its loss at over ₹20 lakh and had also filed an FIR (Cr. No. 235/2023) under the Information Technology Act and the IPC.
Shruthi denied all of it. She said she resigned on medical grounds on 6 April 2022, that the company accepted her resignation and issued a relieving letter after scrutinising her records, and that the suit was an afterthought meant to harass her. The company led one witness and thirteen exhibits. She examined herself and produced four.
Section 27 and the post-employment line
Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act makes an agreement that restrains a person from a lawful profession, trade or business void to the extent of the restraint. The only statutory exception is the sale of goodwill 2.
Indian courts separate restrictions that operate during employment from those that bite after it. In Niranjan Shankar Golikari, the Supreme Court held that negative covenants operating during the contract of employment are generally not a restraint of trade and do not fall under Section 27, and that the considerations are different for restrictions that apply after termination 3. In Superintendence Co. of India v. Krishan Murgai, the Court declined to enforce a post-service restraint against an employee whose services the employer had terminated, and the reported headnote records that a service covenant extending beyond termination is void under Section 27 4. Percept D'Mark v. Zaheer Khan was not an employment case. It concerned a cricketer's right of first refusal under a promotion agreement, but the Court held that a restriction extending beyond the term of the contract is void under Section 27 5.
More recently, in Vijaya Bank v. Prashant B Narnaware (14 May 2025), a two-judge bench confirmed that the validity of any restrictive covenant in an employment agreement is tested against Section 27, and that covenants operating during employment are not a restraint of trade. It also restated that, for standard-form employment contracts, the onus is on the employer to show that a covenant does not restrain lawful employment 6.
The Bengaluru court applied this line to EOX's attempt to keep Shruthi out of a competitor. It said an employer ordinarily cannot prevent a former employee from joining a competitor, or from using general skills, experience and knowledge, merely by calling the restriction a confidentiality clause 7. The judge added that, whatever her reason for resigning, the company could not restrain her from joining another company, even a competitor.
What a confidentiality clause can still do
The court did not strip employers of protection. It said a company can protect trade secrets, proprietary source code, confidential pricing, customer data, technical know-how and other commercially valuable information 8. What it cannot do is control where a former employee works, or whom she serves, using ordinary knowledge and experience.
The distinction is between protecting information and restricting a person. An employer may have a strong case where a former employee takes a pricing model, discloses proprietary technical material, or uses protected customer data. That is different from barring her from a competitor because she picked up skills on the job. A clause is judged on its substance, scope and practical effect, not its title.
One remark deserves care. The judge described the NDA as illegal against the provisions of law. Read alone, that sounds as if NDAs are invalid. In context it targets an NDA being stretched into a bar on joining competitors, and the court was clear that legitimate confidentiality interests remain protectable. Treat the line as dictum tied to this fact pattern, not a general rule against NDAs.
Why EOX lost: the evidence
The court put the initial burden on the company to show a clear contractual breach, unlawful data exfiltration and active interference with its business. It held the company did not discharge that burden, for these reasons 9:
- The investigation report did not name this defendant. The court noted there was no specific allegation against Shruthi in the company's internal report.
- Key witnesses never testified. The employees whose WhatsApp messages and emails were relied on were not examined. Nor were the CEO and COO, who were part of the investigation team.
- The forensic evidence was unreliable. The people who conducted the forensic investigation were not identified. The court also found that the Section 65B certificate did not meet the mandatory requirements and did not explain how another defendant's personal email was accessed.
- No proof she joined a rival or solicited clients. EOX did not show that her new employer was a competitor. No client was examined to say they had been approached, and the email relied on for employee poaching did not mention any defendant.
- Data access was normal at the time. EOX's own witness admitted that employees worked from home during COVID-19 and were allowed to access company data.
- The loss was not proved. There was no chartered accountant's audit report to back the claimed damages.
- The criminal case had stalled. The FIR had not become a charge sheet and was still under investigation.
EOX also relied on a settlement acknowledgment from one of the other former employees, which the defendants said was obtained under duress. The court did not treat it as proof of data sharing or poaching.
The relieving-letter problem
One detail stood out. EOX's own witness accepted that the relieving letter was handed over after the allegations had been under scrutiny for about eight months, around the time the FIR was filed. The judge found it contrary to ordinary corporate logic for a company with a dedicated IT monitoring team to issue a clean relieving letter after so long a review. That, the court said, raised suspicion about the company's conduct and suggested the real aim was to stop the former employees from joining competitors. It called the suit speculative, held the damages unproved, and refused the discretionary relief of a permanent injunction.
A note for careful readers: the judgment gives the relieving-letter date as 14 June 2022 in its narrative of the defence, but as 14 February 2023 in the exhibit list and in the court's own reasoning. The later date is the one that fits the eight-month finding.
Does this make every non-solicitation clause void?
No, and it would be a mistake to read the judgment that way. A non-compete seeks to stop someone from working for a competitor at all. A non-solicitation clause ordinarily targets specific acts, such as approaching named clients or recruiting colleagues. Both can raise Section 27 questions, but the answer depends on the wording, the conduct complained of and the relief sought.
EOX lost mainly because it failed to prove its allegations, not because the court held every non-solicit covenant unenforceable. The court's firm holding is narrower: confidentiality cannot be used as a back door to a non-compete. Where an employer can prove actual misuse of trade secrets or confidential customer data, an injunction aimed at that misuse remains available.
This analysis of the non-solicit point is the author's reading and not a holding of the court. It is also a trial-court ruling, so it should be read alongside the Supreme Court authorities above and the facts of any particular dispute 10.
Practical takeaways
For employers
- Draft confidentiality clauses around defined categories of information, and separate them from general skills and experience gained on the job.
- Do not rely on blanket bars on joining competitors after exit. They are likely to be unenforceable to that extent.
- Preserve evidence when a problem arises: access logs, exit records, forensic images, and a named person responsible for collection. Get the certificate for electronic records right (Section 65B of the Evidence Act, or Section 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, depending on the regime that applies) 11.
- Plan to put decision-makers in the witness box. A report is not evidence unless someone stands behind it.
- Keep your conduct consistent. A clean relieving letter followed by a suit invites questions.
- Quantify losses with financial records, not estimates.
For employees
- Changing jobs within an industry is not misappropriation, and your general skills and experience are yours.
- Client lists, pricing, contracts and similar material are not. Forwarding company files to a personal account can undermine an otherwise strong position.
- Keep your resignation, relieving letter and exit correspondence.
- If you are accused of data theft or breach, take legal advice early.
Notes and sources
The four Supreme Court citations were checked on 22 October 2026 against the Supreme Court's published judgments and standard law-report listings. The case summaries are in the author's words, and the full opinions should be read before relying on them.
This post is general information, not legal advice. The decision discussed is a trial-court ruling and turns heavily on its facts and evidence.
Footnotes
-
M/s EOX Vantage Private Limited v. Shruthi B.S., O.S. No. 3154/2023, XXXV Addl. City Civil & Sessions Judge, Bengaluru, 6 October 2026 (judgment PDF); see also Bar and Bench's report of 21 October 2026. ↩
-
Indian Contract Act, 1872, section 27 (the sole exception is the sale of goodwill). ↩
-
Niranjan Shankar Golikari v. Century Spinning & Manufacturing Co. Ltd., [1967] 2 SCR 378; AIR 1967 SC 1098. ↩
-
Superintendence Company of India (P) Ltd. v. Krishan Murgai, (1981) 2 SCC 246; AIR 1980 SC 1717 (decided 9 May 1980). ↩
-
Percept D'Mark (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. Zaheer Khan, (2006) 4 SCC 227; AIR 2006 SC 3426 (decided 22 March 2006). ↩
-
Vijaya Bank v. Prashant B Narnaware, Civil Appeal No. 11708 of 2016, 2025 INSC 691, decided 14 May 2025 (judgment PDF), paras 11 to 16 and 21. ↩
-
EOX Vantage, judgment, para 10. ↩
-
EOX Vantage, judgment, para 11. ↩
-
EOX Vantage, judgment, paras 8 to 18. ↩
-
Enforceability of a non-solicitation covenant turns on its wording, the conduct alleged and the relief sought. The judgment does not decide that question in general. ↩
-
Indian Evidence Act, 1872, section 65B; Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, section 63. Which applies depends on the governing regime and transitional provisions. ↩



